Category Archives: Theatre Reviews

Down And Out In Paris & London

THEATRE
Down & Out In Paris And London
3 stars ***
Pleasance Courtyard (Venue 33)

THEY HAVE one of the best ideas for a show on this year’s Fringe, the alliance of London-based companies behind this fascinating attempt to link George Orwell’s experience of writing about poverty in Paris in the 1930’s, with the journalist Polly Toynbee’s more recent studies of life on low pay – and on the dole – in the contemporary Britain of benefit sanction and zero hours contracts.

Adapted from the original texts by David Byrne, and co-directed by Byrne and Kate Stanley, the show features a cast of six, and shows huge ingenuity in moving fluidly between the two tales. Some of the staging, particularly of Orwell’s experiences in his surreal Paris rooming-house, is little short of inspired, and its theme – of growing inequality sanctioned by increasingly savage attitudes to those who find themselves in poverty – is perhaps the most timely, and certainly one of the most significant, on this year’s Fringe.

Something comes adrift, though, in the show’s acting style, which ranges from a slightly inappropriate historical jokiness in the Orwell sequences, to a heavily flat-footed political earnestness in portraying Polly Toynbee’s devastating observations of contemporary Britain. The factual material that supports this show is superb and essential, the elements of an interesting staging are there. But the relationship between the actors and the audience needs to be stripped of any trace of a Fringe-style yearning to amuse, and give a strong dose of Brechtian hardness, maturity, and unwillingness to compromise, for this show to achieve anything like its full potential impact.

Joyce McMillan 
Until 31
p. 317
 
ENDS ENDS

Penny Arcade

THEATRE
Penny Arcade: Longing Lasts Longer
4 stars ****
Underbelly Cowgate   (Venue 61)

THERE’S NO DEFINING Penny Arcade.  When she climbs on stage to perform her latest one hour show – wearing a dark blue figure-hugging dress, high heels, and a huge slash of red lipstick – the 65-year-old New York underground diva makes it clear in the first minute or so that this is not theatre, nor stand-up comedy, nor even performance art; it is, she says, something else, a rap or maybe a rant, about a few things that have happened to the human mind during her lifetime.

Penny Arcade’s thesis – presented at high speed, and accompanied by a thundering mix-tape of musical cues from Arcade’s underground past  –  is that everyone under about 40 today is a victim of a huge psychological and marketing experiment, in which everyone is permanently wired to the internet, and constantly targeted by various subtle and not-so-subtle forms of advertising and data-mining.  Her own age-group, by contrast, she sees as a control group, who grew up and experienced their rebellious youth before these ever-more-complex technologies for invading the mind were in place.

Like any exasperated old hippy, she roars out her scorn for a younger generation who no longer rebel, who seem to want to be like their parents; yet there’s a wildness, a passionate dystopian poetry, in her view of the society in which we now live that is somehow anything but commonplace.  It’s not that she is nostalgic for the past, she insists; nostalgia is a cosy and  disempowering emotion.  It’s that she longs for it –  for the freedom that she and her generation enjoyed, in the kind of  unwatched urban space that no longer exists.  And as she says, longing lasts longer than any puny feelings of nostalgia or love; long enough, maybe, to power the kind of struggle that might begin to bring that freedom back.      

Joyce McMillan 
Until 30
p. 356
 
ENDS ENDS       

Lanark (2015)

EIF THEATRE
Lanark
5 stars *****
Royal Lyceum Theatre

IN THE BEGINNING, there is water, or an image of water; light and darkness moving over the face of the deep. We see a man tumbling towards us, like some fallen angel moving through water rather than air; then we see that same man, apparently come to rest on the grubby first-floor balcony of an art-house cinema just a little like the Hillhead Salon. The balcony belongs to the cinema bar, the Elite; and our hero, or anti-hero, stands waiting for the faint glimmer of sun – just a couple of minutes a day – that occasionally lights the horizon of the city where he now dwells.

These are the opening moments of Alasdair Gray’s Lanark, as reimagined by writer David Greig and director Graham Eatough, for this mighty new four-hour stage version of the novel, which was first published in 1981 – although, since we are dealing here with a great post-modernist dedicated to the disruption of form, we begin not at the chronological beginning of the tale, but at the start of what the novel calls Book 3, and Greig calls Act 2, when our hero’s life as a young, asthmatic and eczema-ridden would-be artist called Duncan Thaw, in the relatively familiar setting of postwar Glasgow, has reached a crisis that leads to the transition – drowning, rebirth or shift to a parallel universe – that we have just glimpsed.

It’s this huge imaginative leap – from an all-too recognisable mid-20th century Glasgow of war and rationing, limited horizons and endless petty agonies and sexual humiliations, to the dystopian fantasy-vision of a future Glasgow called Unthank – that gives Alasdair Gray’s great novel its huge, transformative significance in late 20th century Scottish literature, not least because it so clearly links the conventional 20th century narratives of working-class Scottish life to some of the great emerging global genres of the 21st century – to science fiction and fantasy, to dystopian narratives of environmental collapse driven by monstrous corporate greed, and to the idea, less well established in 1981 than today, of parallel universes which are both familiar, and profoundly, strangely different.

And it’s because it embraces and explores all those genres with such confidence and flair, while never losing sight of the essential narrative of Lanark/Thaw/Gray’s astonishing journey, that Greig and Eatough’s new stage version – co-produced by the Edinburgh International Festival and the Citizens’ Theatre – comes so close to the impossible goal of doing full justice to this magnificent novel. The linchpin of the production is Sandy Grierson’s astonishing performance as Lanark himself: thoughtful, self-absorbed, sometimes childlike, yet sexually and creatively driven, and – crucially – possessed of a physical precision and atheticism that enables him to switch in an instant between naturalism, and a much more stylised, metaphorical sense of Lanark’s journey.

Grierson is supported every step of the way, though, by so many other strands of Eatough’s astonishing production. There’s Jessica Hardwick’s terrific matching performance as Rima, the Eve to Lanark’s Adam, and the defining woman of his life, often given the freedom completely to contradict Lanark’s version of his own narrative. There’s the superb ensemble work of a company of ten actors who are also great Scottish theatre-makers, many of them deeply linked to the wave of unstoppable cultural change in Scotland that began in the early 1980’s; the company includes Gerry Mulgrew, George Drennan, Louise Ludgate, Paul Thomas Hickey and Andy Clark, alongside a trio of younger actors.

And there is the constant, inventive stream of shifting imagery, both visual and aural, delivered by designer Laura Hopkins, lighting designer Nigel Edwards, video artist Simon Wainwright, and composer and sound designer Nick Powell, who created a “supergroup “ of musicians influenced by Gray’s work to conjure up on scenes like the unforgettable 50’s-style “Unthank Jazz” sequence, with superb choreography by EJ Boyle; there’s also an inspired use of video, and of the old song Ca’ The Yowes Tae The Knowes, to conjure up the vague remembered glimpses of Glasgow that haunt Lanark when he reaches the brave new world of The Institute, a hospital-like, pseudo-Utopian circle of hell that also features in Act 2 of the story.

Just here and there, there’s perhaps a slight sense of this huge scene-by-scene ingenuity acting as a substitute for a deep analysis of Gray’s themes: then again, an understandable tendency to rely a little too heavily on Grierson’s charismatic central performance, in a way that slightly diminishes Gray’s intense scepticism about Thaw/Lanark’s voice, and its reliability.

In the final, apocalyptic scenes, though – where Greig plays boldly and theatrically with Gray’s questions about the shifting layers of fiction within the story, and even takes us, in a superb moment of graphic imagination, to visit Gray himself , before returning us to Lanark’s poignant final scene at the Unthank Necropolis – this brave adaptation seems wholly at one with the bold, mysterious and infinitely searching spirit of Gray’s novel. On Sunday night, after the premier of Lanark, David Greig sent a twitter message about Alasdair Gray, now 80 years old, and in intensive care in Glasgow. “Thinking of Mr G right now. Wishing him well and wishing he could be with us. He wrote an amazing transformative book. The rest is homage.” What’s certain, though, is that if Alasdair Gray could see this version of Lanark, centre stage at the Edinburgh International Festival, he would know that this story alone represents a great life’s work; and that its impact – not only in Scotland, but across the world of 21st century imagination – has barely begun to be measured.

Joyce McMillan
Until 31
EIF p. 17

ENDS ENDS               

Walking The Tightrope

THEATRE
Walking The Tightrope
4 stars ****
Underbelly Potterrow (Venue 358)

SUBTITLED “the tension between art and politics”, Walking The Tightrope is probably the show on this year’s Fringe that best deserves to be called essential. Put together by the Underbelly in response to last year’s row over the forced withdrawal of a young Israeli company from the Fringe, the show was first seen in London in January, soon after the shocking events at Charlie Hebdo, and offers eight tiny five-minute plays about freedom of expression by a range of leading writers, followed by a half-hour discussion.

Perhaps because of the constraints of the format, the quality of the plays varies wildly. Neil LaBute goes right to the heart of the matter by asking whether it’s OK for a black male performance artist to stage a prolonged rape of a white actress, as a gesture of payback for centuries of oppression. Timberlake Wertenbaker dramatises the ludicrous coommercial pressures on writers who want to say one thing and end up saying something complete different; Cary Churchill mourns the death of meaningful language in her own inimitable style.

Elsewhere, some of the plays have a slightly inward-looking London-theatre-scene feel about them, as – for example – a posh mother and son in Edinburgh for the Fringe argue about the Israeli issue over her copy of the Guardian, and his clown suit; and it’s certainly true that the audience’s enjoyment of the event depends heavily on the quality of the post-show discussion.

At its best, though, Walking The Tightrope offers a series of fine, tight, well-choreographed performances from Cressida Brown’s excellent company of four; as well as a hugely significant opportunity to get to grips with the complex freedom-of-speech issues that increasingly haunt our society, as the right to offend becomes ever more constrained, and groups in conflict increasingly see the media and the arts as arenas not for open discussion, but for demonstrations of their power to silence those with whom they disagree.

Joyce McMillan 
Until 31
p. 382
 
ENDS ENDS       

Traverse Breakfast Plays 2015

THEATRE
Traverse Breakfast Plays: Tomorrow
4 stars ****
Traverse Theatre (Venue 15)

THE ANNUAL Traverse Breakfast Plays season, staged during the Fringe, has become one of the key incubators for brand new writing in Scottish theatre, providing raw material for fully-staged productions throughout the year. Audiences turn up at 9 am, receive a bacon (or egg) roll and a cuppa, and munch their way contentedly through a script-in-hand reading of a new 45-minute play, often featuring an exceptionally high-powered cast.

This year, the season has been designed to emphasise the Traverse’s current network of international links, offering just one play by a Scottish-based writer, and others from China, Ukraine, Egypt, Turkey and Quebec; the same plays will be repeated this week. Faced with the Traverse’s chosen theme of Tomorrow, though, writers generally seem either distressed by it, or inclined to ignore it altogether.

One of the most satisfying plays of the six, for example, is Scottish playwright Linda McLean’s CTRL Z, a brilliantly taut, sound-driven family drama, with plenty of hard-edged humour, about a mother, father and daughter desperately trying to flee into the happy past, as they drive towards the hospital where the son of the family lies close to death. It was given a terrific performance, last week, by a cast led by Lorraine McIntosh and Jimmy Chisholm, with beat-boxer Ball-Zee providing the sound, and Laurie Sansom of the National Theatre of Scotland in the director’s chair; but its only view of the future is that it may well be a lot less fortunate than the present.

Nick Rongjun Yu’s How Could You Slap A Girl? offers a strange, muted dystopian vision of an encounter on a Chinese city street between a 21st century siren of a weeping girl and two men out thieving, for bafflingly complex reasons; This Elephant Speaks Ukrainian, by Natalia Vorozhbyt, is set in the present, in a country where relationships are troubled and disrupted by war. And from Egypt and Turkey, Laila Soliman and Berkun Oya bring strong women’s voices full of foreboding as well as wit and sexual energy, from societies where conflict is intensifying, and freedom closing down.

It’s really only the final play, though – Francois Archambault’s Walt Disney Project, beautifully directed by the Traverse’s Orla O’Loughlin – that gets to grips with the possible politics of future-making, in a world threatened by climate change and social chaos. In this desperate, funny and thought-provoking fantasy, four Quebec independence activists plot to kidnap the cryogenically-preserved body of Walt Disney, and to bring him back to life to put into practice his original EPCOT project for an ideal future city; and with Benny Young acting up a storm as the revived version of Walt, Archambault’s play brings the season to a rousing conclusion, not deep, but somehow strangely believable, as science leads us into the world of the infinitely renewable self.

Joyce McMillan 
Until 30
p. 378
 
ENDS ENDS       

Forest Fringe 2015

_____________________________________________________

JOYCE MCMILLAN on FOREST FRINGE 2015 at Out Of The Blue Drill Hall (Venue 195) and offsite locations, for the Scotsman Festival Supplement, 24.8.15.
_____________________________________________________

4 stars **** (if star rating wanted)

ONE OF ITS offsite venues has had two of its three floors closed by the fire inspectors, another show demands the daily shovelling of 3 tonnes of anthracite, and two favourite associate artists have been bumped from so many possible spaces that they’ve ended up performing in someone’s living-room.

The Forest Fringe, in other words, still has some of that last-minute wildness that used to be associated with the Fringe as a whole; and with Fringe activity ever more concentrated around the university area on the South Side, it seems highly appropriate that this terrific mini Fringe festival – jointly curated by Deborah Pearson, Ira Brand, and the unstoppable Andy Field – not only still fails to appear in the main Fringe programme, but has also taken up residence a mile to the north, at the Out Of The Blue Drill Hall in the Leith Walk heartland of Edinburgh’s year-round creative life.

Yet it’s one of the glorious paradoxes of the Forest Fringe that it increasingly succeeds in being both marginal to the mainstream Fringe – in the most edgy and positive sense of the word – and also central to the creative lives of many leading Fringe artists. Over the two weeks of this year’s programme, the Forest Fringe plays host to a huge range of Fringe stars, from the mighty Tim Etchells of Forced Entertainment, through the Volcano Company of South Wales, to the award-winning Made In China and the astonishing Christopher Brett Bailey, who, next Thursday and Friday, revives his sensational 2014 solo show This Is How We Die. And the festival ends, next weekend, with two days of work under the title Out Of The Woods, programmed by Glasgow’s own experimental Buzzcut festival.

So the past week at Forest Fringe has involved the usual range of the brilliant, the embryonic, and the slightly disappointing. The award-winning company Little Bulb failed to make waves with a sweet, deliberately childish romp-cum-song-cycle about whales called Wails, despite some beautiful singing from Clare Beresford, co-creator of this show with Dominic Conway. And Volcano’s promenade show Black Stuff – a reflection on the coal industry that shaped South Wales, staged off Bonnington Road on a warehouse floor half covered in a thick, jagged layer of anthracite – seemed like a flashback to a Richard Demarco event of the early 1990’s, all vivid splashes of red against black in a dim, dramatically-lit found space, fascinating in its determination to recall the range of international links and migrations fuelled by the coal industry, but slightly self-absorbed in its theatrical style, involving a series of enigmatic, installation-like gestures.

For me, though the shows that reached deepest in the first week were three spare, searching semi-solo performances, all featuring formidable artists in mid-journey. The most perfect was Emma Hall’s remarkable monologue We May Have To Choose, which should have been the most boring show on the Fringe, since it consists of 621 short opinions about almost everything – from Kylie Minogue to the death of the oceans – delivered in 45 minutes. Yet Hall is such a compelling, authoritative performer, the element of simple stylised movement in her performance is so perfectly judged, and the text itself contains such a subtle cumulative poetry about this moment in human history, that the whole show is strangely gripping, and absolutely irresistible.

Then beyond that, there is the absolute joy of a work-in-progress glimpse at Deborah Pearson’s ongoing project History, History, History, which explores how her own family’s history was changed for ever by the Hungarian uprising of 1956. And there is the privilege of spending time in a small room in which Tim Etchells and violinist Aisha Orazbayeva are gradually taking apart the language we use, into endless, concentrated, resonant phrases – “in any order” “it could have been worse” “they told their children the poor were ghosts” – and reassembling it in waves of intense repetition, accompanied by sound from the violin. Etchells performed the experiment he calls Seeping Through for four hours, on Thursday; and although it’s hard to say why, the half hour I spent there was one of the highlights of my week, an intense immersion in the way we use words but often fail to hear them, that seemed to cleanse my brain of all the sound and fury of the Fringe, and leave me ready – like Forest Fringe, which opens its second-week programme today – to start all over again.

Joyce McMillan 
Until 30, with further performances of Black Stuff untl 28.
Details: http://forestfringe.co.uk/edinburgh2015/events/2015-08/
 
ENDS ENDS       

Sequamur

THEATRE
Sequamur
3 stars ***
Assembly Rooms (Venue 20)

FOR THE LAST TWO YEARS, British stages have been full of shows commemorating the First World War and the carnage it brought; but few have approached the story from as interesting and conflicted a perspective as this latest show from Proiseact Nan Eilean, Scotland’s Gaelic Arts Agency.

Set in and around the Nicolson Institute, Stornoway’s famous seconday school, the play is set both in 1914 and in 1934, at the unveiling of plaque to the fallen; and it centres on the troubled figure of the school’s head teacher William J Gibson, a classicist who in 1914 encouraged his pupils to enlist with many a rousing quote from the ancients, and then spent the rest of his life regretting his role in urging a generation of young men towards their deaths.

Performed in Gaelic, with a simultaneous headphone translation available, Iain Macrae’s production sometimes has a stiff and awkward air, particularly in the playing of the older characters. The three young men in the cast play their brief roles with real passion, though. And there are some fine, thoughtful visual images to set the scene and drive the drama along, not least the kind of archive footage of which we can never see too much; lest we forget all those who died for a country that often barely recognised them and their humanity, whether because of class, race, or – as in this case – a language once driven close to extinction, but now slowly rediscovering its public voice.

Joyce McMillan 
Until 24
p. 365
 
ENDS ENDS       

Spectretown

THEATRE
SpectreTown
3 stars ****
Assembly Hall (Venue 35)

IT’S A brave, complex and ambitious show, this latest production from Elspeth Turner’s Edinburgh-based Stoirm Og company, co-produced by Cumbernauld Theatre. Set in and near Aberdeen a century ago and today, Turner’s 80-minute play pursues Stoirm Og’s interest in Scotland’s languages, telling a complex time-shifting tale of Meg and Doddie, an engaged couple working on a big Aberdeenshire farm in the early 1900’s, and Nan and Stanley, their modern-day counterparts, who meet in the Aberdeen charity shop where Stanley volunteers.

The language therefore shifts in complex ways from a rich traditional Doric to modern north-east street vernacular. The story is also fiercely compicated, involving a kist (chest) full of memories that trigger a kind of time-travel, and precious reel-to-reel recordings from the mid-20th century of Doddie, once a ploughman linked to one of the north-east’s ancient rural brotherhoods of horsemen.

In the end, the play begins to collapse under the weight of its own multiple themes, which range from political radicalisation and religious fundamentalism in early 20th century rural Scotland, through the politics of sexual frustration and violence, to the strange interaction between emasculated, unemployed Stanley, his boss Izzy, and Nan, who earns her living as a lap-dancer. But the show has some haunting elements of design, a fine score played live by composer Matt Regan, three strong performances from Bridget McCann, Mark Wood and Elspeth Turner herself, and some elegant direction from Matthew Lenton of Vanishing Point; and audiences in Scotland now have a chance to see it in local venues across the country, as it tours from Greenock to Inverness and Buckie, during September.

Joyce McMillan 
Until 31
p. 368
 
ENDS ENDS       

Paul Bright’s Confessions Of A Justified Sinner (2015)

EIF THEATRE
Paul Bright’s Confessions Of A Justified Sinner
4 stars ****
Queen’s Hall

SOME WALKED out, but many stayed: for this astonishing 2013 show by cutting-edge Scottish company Untitled Projects, now revived for an Edinburgh Festival run, is a strange and alluring hybrid beast, part exhibition and installation, part lecture, part sequence of film-clips, part thrilling solo performance by the lone actor on stage, George Anton.

It’s also part work of genius, and part self-obsessed meta-theatrical romp through the 1980’s Scottish cultural scene; for in essence, Paul Bright’s Confessions tells the real or imaginary story of Paul Bright, a young and rebellious Scottish film director of the late 1980’s, and of his doomed attempt to create a new screen version of James Hogg’s great 1824 novel The Private Memoirs And Confessions Of A Justified Sinner, filmed in locations across Scotland from Arthur’s Seat and Traquair House to a Glasgow east end pub.

Somehow , though – through their cheek, their chutzpah, the sheer vividness with they conjure up a particular cultural moment, and the ever-more-striking brilliance of Anton’s bravura performance as an actor who was once Bright’s creative soulmate – director Stewart Laing, writer Pamela Carter and their team succeed in creating something that transcends theatrical in-jokery.

So that in the end, almost against the odds, Paul Bright’s Confessions builds towards a hugely moving final moment of insight: not only into the messy business of creativity, but into the conflicted soul of Scotland itself, the land whose deep and driven Calvinist inheritance, so brilliantly exposed in Hogg’s novel, finds a strange echo in this 20th century tale of a man who clearly sees himself as one of the creative “elect”, but who in the end finds only self-destruction and obscurity, and a long wait for a predictably early death.

Joyce McMillan 
Until 22
EIF p. 21
 
ENDS ENDS       

Two Minute Manifesto

SPOKEN WORD, CABARET
Two Minute Manifesto
3 stars ***
Traverse Theatre (Venue 15)

IT’S DIFFICULT TO AVOID the presence of David Greig in Edinburgh this year, with his huge stage version of Lanark opening in the international festival  this weekend, and his continuing efforts – in response to last year’s freedom- of-speech row – to make sure that the voices of young Palestinian artists are heard on the fringe. 

If you want to encounter the man himself in particularly relaxed form, though – and to catch a glimpse of the kind of cheerful creative culture that grew up around last year’s referendum debate in Scotland – then you shouldn’t hesitate to head along to the Traverse on Monday morning for the last of three festival ediions of Two Minute Manifesto, a year-round series of sessions, co-chaired by David Greig and Scottish Green Party candidate Sarah Beattie Smith, that involve poetry, music, and a series of short political proposals, followed by a bit of punditry and debate, and some light-touch audience participation.

Last week, the session featured Scottish-based radical poet Harry Giles and novelist Sara Sheridan with their manifesto ideas (Giles engagingly wanted a ten-year programme to abolish the police!), along with magnificent poetry from Robert Somyne of London, and a few pensive songs from Gordon Mcintyre of Edinburgh band Ballboy; and although the line-up changes with every session, the sheer richness of the Edinburgh Festival scene guarantees some impressive art and politics, for those willing to get out of bed early – or stay up all night – to make it to Monday’s 10 am session.

Joyce McMillan 
Until 24i
Not in Fringe programme
 
ENDS ENDS